TUTTLE PRIVATE CEMETERY
Cemetery Road (off Montauk Highway)
Eastport, Suffolk County, NY 11941
[40 49' 33" N, 72 43' 18" W]

Based on gravestone inscriptions and on genealogical records of Robert Brown

Note: This cemetery is currently part of the Eastport Cemetery
 

NAME BIRTH DEATH REMARKS POSITION
Tuthill, Daniel Sep 18 1761 Mar 18 1845 Son of 'Hunter' John Tuthill and Sarah Wells row 1 stone 1
Tuthill, Sarah 1765 Sep 15 1852 Nee Parshall. "relict [widow] of Daniel Tuthill."  Dau. of David Parshall and Elizabeth Swezey. row 1 stone 2
Tuttle, Wells Apr 16 1803 Aug 19 1887 "Farewell to friends our memory keep while in death's arms our bodies sleep."  Son of Daniel Tuthill and Sarah Parshall row 1 stone 3
Tuttle, Nellie Oct 29 1803 Apr 22 1885 Nee Hallock. Wife of Wells Tuttle. Married 4/24/1823.  AKA "Penelope"  Dau. of Nathan Reeves Hallock and Jerusha Raynor row 1 stone 3
Tuttle, Jonathan Vail Apr 22 1842 Jul 14 1927 Son of Wells and Nellie row 1 stone 4
Tuttle, Mary Jane Mar 25 1845 Sep 16 1911 Nee. Black. First husband William Britton/Brittain row 1 stone 4
Tuttle, Sarah Elizabeth Oct 25 1868 Mar 13 1925 Unmarried dau. of Jonathan and Mary Jane.  AKA Sadie row 1 stone 4
Tuttle, George Parshall 1788 Feb 28 1816 Son of Daniel and Sarah. His wife was Jerusha Culver, (buried elsewhere?) row 2 stone 1
Tuttle, Daniel Wesley Feb 22 1824 Mar 14 1892 "The Lord knoweth them that are His"  Son of Wells and Nellie row 3 stone 1
Tuttle, Mary Caroline Mar 27 1826 Aug 18 1892 Nee Rogers. Wife of Daniel Wesley, & dau of Oliver and Abigail Rogers row 3 stone 1
Tuttle, Erastus Wells Apr 16 1876 Jun 2 1922 Son of George Chauncey & Hannah Matilda row 3 stone 2
Tuttle, Ida Jane Oct 11 1869 Aug 2 1967 Nee Dayton. Dau. of William Dayton and Emily Smith row 3 stone 2
Tuttle, <infant>   Dec 22 1856 "Daughter of D P and Catherine A Tuttle" row 4 stone 1
Tuttle, George Chauncey Nov 22 1833 Oct 23 1887 "Not lost but gone before"  Son of Wells and Nellie row 5 stone 1
Tuttle, Hannah Matilda Aug 7 1836 Jan 10 1914 Nee Tuttle. Wife of George Chauncey.  Dau of John Culver Tuttle and Harriet Ruland row 5 stone 1
Gordon, Daniel S. Nov 23 1833 Dec 10 1865 AE 32y 7d row 6 stone 1
Tuttle, Nellie M. 1863 Aug 26 1866 Dau. of David and Catherine row 6 stone 2
Tuttle, David Parshall Nov 13 1829 Dec 28 1911 Son of Wells and Nellie row 6 stone 3
Tuttle, Catherine A. May 30 1834 Apr 18 1882 Nee Seaman. Wife of David Parshall row 6 stone 3

Note:  I arbitrarily chose "Row 1" to identify the grave sites on the west side of the cemetery.  Row 6 is on the east side, adjoining the Eastport Cemetery.  Within each row I have arbitrarily numbered the stones from the north side to the south side of the cemetery.

The above stones existed as of November 2006.  There are several unmarked graves, particularly in rows 2 through 6.

Take a look at the Thy Testimonies website.